Sierra Student Coalition Logo

Sierra Student Coalition Spring 2006 Election Results

This election was conducted for the Sierra Student Coalition by FairVote.

If you have comments about this page, please contact jerdonek@fairvote.org.

Name Change Referendum

Shall the SSC change its name from the "Sierra Student Coalition" to the "Student Sierra Club"?

Two-thirds (66.7%) threshold required for passage.

Yes 46 55.4%
No 37 44.6%
Votes 83 100.0%
Undervotes 1 N/A
Total 84 N/A

55.4% does not meet the threshold, so the referendum does not pass.

Executive Committee Election

Seven (7) candidates to be elected using single transferable voting (STV), also known as ranked choice voting (RCV). There were 12 candidates. The winners are:

See below for a brief description of RCV and the winning threshold, the full results and candidate list, and some stats.

Here is the ballot file.

Ranked Choice Voting

"While the right to rule belongs to the majority, the right to representation belongs to all."

Ranked choice voting makes every vote count — representing the greatest possible number of voters fairly. A multi-seat body elected using RCV is an accurate cross-section of the entire voting body, including majority and minority views alike.

How does it work? Voters rank the candidates 1, 2, 3 and so on. If your first choice loses or wins with votes to spare, your unused vote goes to your second choice. This continues until all candidates are elected.

In this kind of multi-seat election, RCV is a proportional voting system. In a single-winner election where a majority is necessary to win, RCV is also called instant runoff voting.

Winning Threshold

Candidates win in ranked choice voting by reaching the winning threshold. Take the number of votes in the first round (82) and divide by one more than the number of seats (7 + 1 = 8). Add one to this number and remove the fraction to obtain the winning threshold!

  Votes Seats V/(S+1)+1 Threshold
Winning Threshold Calculation 82 7 11.25 11.00

In English, the winning threshold is the fewest number of votes a candidate needs to be guaranteed a seat.

(In our case of 82 voters, at most 7 candidates can each get 11 votes. A lower threshold of 10 would allow 8 candidates. So the threshold is 11.)

Round-by-Round Report

In ranked choice voting the ballots are counted in rounds.

Winners are shown in bold. Note that candidate Nathan Wyeth withdrew before the tally, so rankings indicating him were skipped and not counted.

Rounds 1-5

  Round 1   Round 2   Round 3   Round 4   Round 5
Rachel Ackoff 21.000 -10.000 11.000   11.000   11.000   11.000
Erica Stout 16.000   16.000 -5.000 11.000   11.000   11.000
Sasha Shahidi 9.000 +0.952 9.952 +0.938 10.890   10.890   10.890
Andrew Nazdin 6.000   6.000 +1.250 7.250 +2.625 9.875   9.875
Nora Sharp 4.000 +2.857 6.857 +0.938 7.795   7.795   7.795
Juan Martinez 6.000 +0.952 6.952 +0.938 7.890   7.890 +1.000 8.890
Katherine McEachern 5.000 +2.857 7.857   7.857   7.857 +1.000 8.857
Bret O'Connor 7.000   7.000 +0.312 7.313   7.313   7.313
Nick Knobbe 3.000 +1.905 4.905   4.905   4.905 +1.000 5.905
Juliana Williams 3.000   3.000   3.000   3.000 -3.000 0.000
Arjun Shukla 2.000   2.000 +0.625 2.625 -2.625 0.000    
Nathan Wyeth*                  
Continuing 82.000 -0.476 81.524 0.000 81.524 0.000 81.524 0.000 81.524
Exhausted 0.000 +0.476 0.476   0.476   0.476   0.476
Undervotes 2.000   2.000   2.000   2.000   2.000
Total 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000

Round 1-5 Notes: Ackoff and Stout both win in round 1, with the surplus votes recounted towards the next choices in rounds 1 and 2. Shukla is defeated in round 3, with those votes recounted towards the next choices. Williams is similarly defeated in round 4.

Rounds 5-9

  Round 5   Round 6   Round 7   Round 8   Round 9
Rachel Ackoff 11.000   11.000   11.000   11.000   11.000
Erica Stout 11.000   11.000   11.000   11.000   11.000
Sasha Shahidi 10.890 +1.476 12.366 -1.366 11.000   11.000   11.000
Andrew Nazdin 9.875 +2.000 11.875   11.875 -0.875 11.000   11.000
Nora Sharp 7.795 +1.476 9.271 +0.529 9.800 +0.290 10.090 +5.182 15.272
Juan Martinez 8.890 +0.476 9.366 +0.250 9.616 +0.120 9.736 +1.295 11.031
Katherine McEachern 8.857 +0.476 9.333 +0.331 9.665 +0.221 9.886 +0.312 10.198
Bret O'Connor 7.313   7.313 +0.256 7.568 +0.221 7.789 -7.789 0.000
Nick Knobbe 5.905 -5.905 0.000            
Juliana Williams 0.000                
Arjun Shukla                  
Nathan Wyeth*                  
Continuing 81.524 0.000 81.524 0.000 81.524 -0.023 81.501 -1.000 80.501
Exhausted 0.476   0.476   0.476 +0.023 0.499 +1.000 1.499
Undervotes 2.000   2.000   2.000   2.000   2.000
Total 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000 0.000 84.000

Round 5-9 Notes: Knobbe is defeated in round 5. In round 6, Shahidi and Nazdin win election and those surplus votes transferred in rounds 6 and 7. O'Connor is defeated in round 8 and those votes transferred. In round 9, Sharp, Martinez, and McEachern are the only candidates remaining, so they win and round out the elected seven.

Voter Representation

This chart shows how many voters had one of their top choices elected: how many had their first choice elected; how many had their second choice elected, but not their first; and so on.

Pie chart showing percent of voters represented
#1 choice elected 81.7% (67.0)
#2 choice elected 13.4% (11.0)
#3 choice elected 3.7% (3.0)
#4 choice elected 1.2% (1.0)

So 82.0% of the voters had their first choice elected, 95.0% one of their first two choices, and 99.0% one of their first three choices!

Number of Candidates Ranked

This chart shows how many choices voters ranked on their ballot. On the far left is the number ranking a single candidate. On the far right is the number ranking all candidates.

Bar graph showing number of candidates ranked on each ballot

Average number of candidates ranked: 8.5

Median number of candidates ranked: 8